Day 3 of classes and already I'm falling behind with my reading! Tonight I ate dinner in my room and will stay up late drafting the introduction to my first paper.
Just a quick quote from the amazing John Dewey, the father of progressive education (written in 1934):
"The old education emphasized the necessity for provision of definite subject-matter and activities, which are necessities for right education. The weakness was that its imagination did not go beyond provision of a rigid environment of subject-matter drawn from sources remote from any concrete experiences taught."
Interpretation: content is important but should derive from direct experiences.
Dewey also wrote: "...no prescribed and ready-made scheme can determine the exact subject-matter for the educative growth of each individual, since each sets a new problem and calls for at least a somewhat different emphasis in either subject-matter or angle of presentation."
Interpretation: alter both content and delivery to better meet the needs of the learner.
Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Tuesday, January 28, 2014
Child Centered vs Content Centered
I can't believe my good fortune in being able to spend two full weeks at Columbia, alongside 18 other independent school leaders from around the world, reading and reflecting on some of the great educational issues of the day.
Today we discussed several texts, among them an article written by Philip Jackson, on the two alternative views of education: child-centered and subject-centered. The first of these he calls the transformative approach and the latter the mimetic approach. In the transformative mode teachers are focused on leading children to a discovery of themselves, and in the process of their values, interests, and morals. The teacher is the wise and knowledgeable guide. In the mimetic mode, teachers view students as empty vessels to fill with information, the end result being a student able to recite and recall that which has been deposited in her, without having any particular awareness of the value or purpose of that meaning. The teacher, of course, is the fount of knowledge who skillfully imparts that knowledge to his students
While this polarized view of teaching is perhaps useful in isolating extremes, it is rare that we find teachers who are solely practitioners in only one of the two modes. We all know skillful teachers who find ways to deliver content while also engaging students in meaningful application of that information.
Finding the right balance of content and process has always been a challenge for teachers. Each day they must make decisions about which content to teach, and which to omit. Which details of the Civil War do students need to know, for example? Should the content be the same for all students? Should students who are interested in warfare spend more time on battlefield strategies, while those more interested in social history learn more about the lives of those staying back keeping the homefires burning? With the explosion of information that has occured with the internet, this question has only become more complicated, and the answers less clear.
I think an interesting way to think about this problem is presented by Will Richardson, our next Global Education speaker. Richardson talks about "just in time" education vs. "just in case" education to suggest that the old model of teaching kids things "just in case" they might someday need it, should give way to a new model of teaching where kids are engaged in solving problems and taught skills and information "just in time," when they need it. This is certainly worth thinking about.
Today we discussed several texts, among them an article written by Philip Jackson, on the two alternative views of education: child-centered and subject-centered. The first of these he calls the transformative approach and the latter the mimetic approach. In the transformative mode teachers are focused on leading children to a discovery of themselves, and in the process of their values, interests, and morals. The teacher is the wise and knowledgeable guide. In the mimetic mode, teachers view students as empty vessels to fill with information, the end result being a student able to recite and recall that which has been deposited in her, without having any particular awareness of the value or purpose of that meaning. The teacher, of course, is the fount of knowledge who skillfully imparts that knowledge to his students
While this polarized view of teaching is perhaps useful in isolating extremes, it is rare that we find teachers who are solely practitioners in only one of the two modes. We all know skillful teachers who find ways to deliver content while also engaging students in meaningful application of that information.
Finding the right balance of content and process has always been a challenge for teachers. Each day they must make decisions about which content to teach, and which to omit. Which details of the Civil War do students need to know, for example? Should the content be the same for all students? Should students who are interested in warfare spend more time on battlefield strategies, while those more interested in social history learn more about the lives of those staying back keeping the homefires burning? With the explosion of information that has occured with the internet, this question has only become more complicated, and the answers less clear.
I think an interesting way to think about this problem is presented by Will Richardson, our next Global Education speaker. Richardson talks about "just in time" education vs. "just in case" education to suggest that the old model of teaching kids things "just in case" they might someday need it, should give way to a new model of teaching where kids are engaged in solving problems and taught skills and information "just in time," when they need it. This is certainly worth thinking about.
Friday, January 24, 2014
Portrait of an MV Teacher
Click here to read the Portrait of an MV Teacher.
- What do you think?
- Does this portrait of a teacher capture the essential qualities of an MV teacher?
- What do you like?
- What's missing?
Portrait of an MV Graduate
Click
here to read the Portrait of a Maumee Valley graduate.
- What do you think?
- Does this portrait capture the essential qualities?
- What do you like?
- What is missing?
Monday, January 13, 2014
College Admission is About More Than Scores
Last night I watched the movie Admission, a film that lampoons the admission process at Princeton. I didn't think the film was particularly funny or even clever, but it did highlight the extraordinarily difficult time selective universities have in making admissions decisions from a large pool of highly qualified students. The movie underscores the fact that high test scores, unrealistically high GPAs, strong AP scores, and a host of extracurricular activities only make an applicant look identical to the other 30,000 applicants. In the film, the admissions mantra was that there is no secret to getting into Princeton, and they encouraged their applicants to show passion, and to "be themselves." While much of the movie was unbelievable, this message was right on. As Yong Zhao says in World Class Learners, the way to gain entry into selective colleges is to "be interesting."
Embracing this point of view leads to the inevitable question: How do we help students become interesting people? The best way, perhaps the only way, is to help students discover and nurture their passions. This is the underlying driver of the MV2020 initiative. We are asking questions from what content we teach, to which methods are most effective, to how we organize students and time. Because of the globalization of education (particularly at the university level) and the explosion of qualified college candidates from around the world, such a top to bottom review and revision of our program is critical if we are to remain relevant.
Embracing this point of view leads to the inevitable question: How do we help students become interesting people? The best way, perhaps the only way, is to help students discover and nurture their passions. This is the underlying driver of the MV2020 initiative. We are asking questions from what content we teach, to which methods are most effective, to how we organize students and time. Because of the globalization of education (particularly at the university level) and the explosion of qualified college candidates from around the world, such a top to bottom review and revision of our program is critical if we are to remain relevant.
There is no question that MV graduates are extraordinarily well prepared to succeed in college. Our faculty does a great job of ensuring that even our top students are challenged, and we give kids the kind of personal attention that helps them to be independent and prepared for the rigors of college. But is that enough? Not anymore. If we want our students to have their “best opportunities in college,” as our Mission promises, then we are going to need to help them stand out from the crowd.
As we begin to explore ways to further “personalize” a Maumee Valley education, we look to those things we already do to encourage passion and exploration, and build on them. Things like the “Genius Hour” program in the Lower School, the weekly Activity Period in the Middle School, and the Winterim Program in the Upper School, all provide students the opportunity to ask questions and pursue interests. These are the kinds of learning experiences we need to build upon.
Monday, December 16, 2013
Welcome
We are in the midst of a revolution in education. Never has information been more readily available, nor have students ever had so many interesting options. Online learning opportunities abound and there has been an exponential growth in our understanding of how people learn, leading to better teaching. Technology has evolved to the point that it is ubiquitous and provides opportunities for adaptive learning that completely individualizes instruction. Our nation is careening toward national standards and high stakes testing to compete with countries like Finland and South Korea, while other countries like China are looking toward the US schools to learn how to teach creativity, grit, and entrepreneurship. The most selective universities in the country are flooded with qualified applicants from US schools and from around the world, and are having to rethink their entire admissions processes.
What an exciting time to be in education! These changes led author Will Richardson to ask, Why School?, and lead us to explore the challenges and opportunities they present to our school. This blog will serve as a resource page for me and the MV faculty to share ideas with our entire community, and a forum for our community to react to them.
We will regularly post links to interesting articles, books, blogs, and videos, and will occasionally write our reflections about some of the implications. We will also post a copy of the soundtrack and slides from the recent “Neighborhood Gatherings,” and a summary of the MV2020 Vision document.
You should check back regularly for updates.
What an exciting time to be in education! These changes led author Will Richardson to ask, Why School?, and lead us to explore the challenges and opportunities they present to our school. This blog will serve as a resource page for me and the MV faculty to share ideas with our entire community, and a forum for our community to react to them.
We will regularly post links to interesting articles, books, blogs, and videos, and will occasionally write our reflections about some of the implications. We will also post a copy of the soundtrack and slides from the recent “Neighborhood Gatherings,” and a summary of the MV2020 Vision document.
You should check back regularly for updates.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)